Abortion Clinic Killed This Woman in a Botched Abortion, Then Her Organs Were Harvested
When
Lakisha Wilson renewed her driver’s license on May 25, 2012, she
checked the permission box to become an organ donor. She had no idea
that she would be dead less than two years later, or that a simple flick
of the pen at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles would become a roadblock to
preventing those responsible for her death from being held accountable.
Lakisha Wilson was a 22-year old African-American woman who died in
March 2014, as the result of second trimester abortion complications at
Preterm, an abortion facility located in Cleveland, Ohio.
Her death not only raised questions about patient safety at the
high-volume abortion business, but also brought to light another
extremely sensitive issue that has rarely been discussed — until now.
That issue concerns the high-pressure tactics of organ procurement
organizations to secure organ donation consent from families of women
like Wilson, who die from abortion complications and other surgeries.
The news has been full of reports in recent months about
organ procurement companies contracting with Planned Parenthood and other abortion businesses to obtain
aborted baby remains
for “donation,” often to the financial benefit of both the abortion
provider and the organ procurement organization. However, there is
another aspect to the issue of organ procurement involving
dead abortion patients, which also deserves public discussion.
Certainly, organ donation to those in need of transplants is a noble
and life-saving decision under most circumstances. At any given time,
there are over 121,000 people awaiting organ transplants in the U.S. It
is true that some tragically die before a suitable donor can be found.
“We support those who wish to willingly become organ donors. In most
cases, it saves lives and gives the families of donors comfort knowing
that the death of their loved one will enable others to live,” said
Operation Rescue President Troy Newman. “However, in Lakisha Wilson’s
case, we have serious concerns about how the donation process was
handled, and how it may have actually protected those responsible for
her death.”
Second-Trimester Abortion Gone Bad
Wilson’s nightmare began on March 21, 2014, when she reported to the
Preterm abortion clinic on Shaker Boulevard in Cleveland, Ohio, for an
abortion at 19 weeks, 4 days, according to a
Preterm ultrasound report that was done about two weeks earlier. (Ultrasound
results from a different facility placed her closer to 23 weeks at the time of her abortion.)
Wilson suffered almost immediate complications during her second trimester abortion, which was conducted by Preterm abortionist
Lisa Perriera.
Even though Wilson’s blood pressure was dropping fast, Perriera
finished the abortion before tending to Wilson’s dangerously escalating
medical emergency. By then, Wilson had stopped breathing and suffered
cardiac arrest.
According to
public 911 records obtained through open records requests and
medical records
leaked to Operation Rescue, it was about thirty minutes after Wilson
suffered respiratory arrest that an ambulance was finally called. A
Preterm employee told a 911 dispatcher that Wilson was “not breathing at
all.” EMS workers arriving at the scene (after a delay caused by a
malfunctioning elevator)
noted
that Wilson indeed was not breathing. Her pupils were fixed and
dilated. They were able to restart her heart and provide oxygenation by
“bagging” her.
Wilson was eventually transported to the University Hospital Case
Medical Center where she was evaluated and given four units of packed
red blood cells to treat an apparent hemorrhage that was the source of
her cardio-respiratory failure. She was transferred to the Intensive
Care unit, placed on life support, and listed in critical but stable
condition.
Somewhere along the way, it was determined that Wilson was “brain dead.”
Lifebanc
At the University Hospital Case Medical Center, an organ procurement organization (OPO) called
Lifebanc began evaluating Wilson for organ harvesting.
Lifebanc is a non-profit OPO based in Cleveland, which claims to work with 20 Ohio hospitals to:
• Identify donors.
• Match them to patients on the National Transplant Waiting List.
• Arrange for the harvesting of organs by teams of surgeons.
• Arrange transport to hospitals for transplantation into suitable recipients.
OPOs look for donor candidates among those who are hospitalized due
to life-threatening brain injuries as the result of traffic accidents,
strokes, or lack of oxygen, according to a
video posted on Lifebanc’s web site, which was produced by
OrganDonor.gov a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Family Approached
After Wilson’s family was notified that Lakisha had been taken to the
hospital, they rushed to be by her side only to learn that their worst
fears were realized. As they gathered in a hospital waiting room in
shock and disbelief, a representative — allegedly from Preterm — first
approached them, seeking permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
CLICK LIKE IF YOU’RE PRO-LIFE!
Wilson’s grief-stricken family looked at the Preterm representative
as part of the reason why their loved one lay comatose in a hospital bed
hooked to machines that artificially controlled her life functions.
There were questions about Lakisha’s death – questions that had not
been answered. How could a healthy 22-year old woman die from what
everyone said was one of the safest and common surgical procedures in
America? What went wrong and who was responsible?
Wilson’s family refused to sign the consent forms so that the organ harvesting could begin.
Thus began a high-pressure effort to secure the family’s permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
High Demand
Why were Wilson’s organs wanted so badly?
Since African Americans are more prone to suffering from diabetes and high blood pressure than other racial groups, they are
more prone to organ failure.
It is true that organs are not supposed to be matched to donors based
on race, but there are certain important blood type characteristics and
tissue markers that are shared more often between people of the same
racial make-up. These markers help determine transplant compatibility.
In America, about 30% of all organ recipients are African American,
making them the largest minority population in need of organs for
transplant. However, this racial group comprises only about 18% of all
organ donors. Therefore, there exists a critical shortage of organs
compatible for transplant into those of African American heritage.
As a young, healthy African American woman, who succumbed to a lack
of oxygen to the brain, Wilson’s organs would have been in high demand.
Father Adamant about Not Consenting
Over the course of the next few days, Lifebanc had a vested interest in Lakisha Wilson.
At first, all testing on Wilson was ordered by hospital physicians. But on March 26, that changed.
Lifebanc ran a
search
of the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles Organ Donor database and
discovered that Wilson had given her consent to “make an anatomical
gift” of her organs upon her death.
With
this document in hand, Lifebanc did not need the family to consent
before the organ harvesting could begin. That same day, it
ordered testing to ensure that life support devices were properly placed and that Wilson’s organs were in good condition.
The next day, Wilson’s father was again approached by Lifebanc with
the request to harvest Lakisha’s organs. He adamantly refused to sign
any documents. In fact, Wilson’s records include a
hand-written note signed by Wilson’s dad, which read:
March 27, 2014. Life banc [sic] my daughter Lakisha
Wilson died under suspicious circumstances. At this time the Cuyahoga
County Coroner is investigating the cause of died [sic]. I adamantly
refuse to sign papers giving my consent for organ donation. Life banc
[sic] personnel are strongly aware of my concerns.
Lifebanc chose to ignore Wilson’s father. Paperwork was processed
that noted her father’s refusal to complete or sign any of the consent
and policy forms. While Lifebanc’s actions were technically legal, they
were ethically dubious.
Organs Procured
Over the next two days, March 27 and 28, Lifebanc ordered
additional testing
on Wilson to make sure her organs remained disease free and in good
condition for harvesting and transplant while the paperwork was
processed. Wilson wasn’t treated like a person any more. She had become a
commodity.
On March 28, against the expressed wishes of her family, and knowing
that there were questions about Wilson’s care and treatment during her
fatal abortion, Lifebanc essentially gutted Lakisha Wilson and
removed
nearly every basic internal organ, including her heart, lungs, liver,
gallbladder, pancreas, abdominal aorta, inferior vena cava, kidneys,
ureters, adrenal glands and their adjacent connective tissue.
Autopsy on Incomplete Cadaver
Thus, when the coroner, Dr. Joseph A. Felo, received what was left of
Lakisha Wilson’s body, he was forced to conduct an autopsy on a partial
cadaver. He also lacked the remains of Wilson’s aborted baby, and had
to rely on Preterm’s medical records for certain “facts” about the
supposed gestational age of her pregnancy.
Felo concluded in
Wilson’s autopsy
that she died from cardiac arrest resulting in brain damage from oxygen
deprivation, a known complication to a therapeutic abortion. In an
interview
with an investigator with the Ohio Department of Health, Felo explained
that because cardiac arrest is a known complication to a therapeutic
abortion, Wilson death “did not indicate medical malpractice.”
However, his conclusions were based on insufficient data. Why had
Wilson hemorrhaged and why wasn’t her condition treated in time by
Preterm’s abortionist, Lisa Perriera? Why did she wait a half hour after
Wilson stopped breathing to call 911?
Without Lakisha’s organs or her babies’ remains, there was no way to
determine the full extent of complications or whether Preterm staff
members were telling the truth.
Just as Wilson’s father feared if organ donation were to take place,
the “suspicious circumstances” under which his daughter died would never
be sufficiently explained.
“This complete disregard for the wishes of the family or
consideration for the circumstances of Wilson’s death make Lifebanc’s
actions troubling,” said Newman. “Wilson was kept on life support for
days — not to treat her, but for the sole purpose of keeping her organs
viable for harvesting and transplant.”
$25 Million per Year
Lifebanc is a non-profit organization that takes in about $25 million each year. According the company’s
990 tax report from 2013, the most recent year available, Lifebanc ended that fiscal year with net assets totaling more than $14 million.
The Chief Executive Officer of Lifebanc is Gordon Bowen, whose salary
$253,000 yearly with over $43,000 in additional compensation.
Lifebanc’s Medical Director is Dr. Daniel Lebovitz, a Cleveland-based
pediatrician who to be affiliated with a number of Ohio hospitals. His
annual salary in 2013 from Lifebanc alone was $101, 347.
“There appears to be good money in the organ procurement business,”
said Newman. “Combine a case with high-demand organs with financial
incentives, and it looks like we have a recipe for high-pressure tactics
to obtain consent for organ donation that include ignoring a family’s
wishes and the need for a thorough investigation into a suspicious
death.”
Others Targeted
Wilson is not the only patient suffering an abortion-related death that has been targeted for organ donation.
In 2005, Christin Gilbert, a 19-year old with Down syndrome, died
from complications to a third-trimester abortion in Wichita, Kansas.
Since Gilbert succumbed to sepsis, an infection that caused several of
her organs to fail, only her
eyes were harvested for eventual corneal transplant.
Free to Kill Again
In Gilbert’s case, the abortionists involved in her death, LeRoy
Carhart and George Tiller, were absolved of responsibility. This time,
it was not due to the inability to reach conclusions due to harvested
organs, but for politically-motivated reasons. Because he was never held
accountable, Carhart was free to kill again.
On February 7, 2014, he did just that. Another of Carhart’s third-trimester abortion patients,
Jennifer Morbelli,
died from complications. Her organs were too compromised to be suitable
for donation. Again, Carhart was not held responsible. There is a
likelihood that yet another of his abortion patients will die.
It is true that donating organs saves lives, and that is indeed
noble. However, abortion-related deaths pose unique situations that
should be taken into consideration by organ donation companies.
When organ donation conceals the incompetency of abortionists, as may
have occurred in the Wilson case, this could leave a dangerous
abortionist to kill again. Lives are endangered by the inability to
perform a thorough autopsy on a complete cadaver and get to the bottom
of what happened to cause the deaths of otherwise healthy women.
Michael Crichton’s “Coma”
The
Wilson tragedy hearkens to mind the Michael Crichton’s 1978 movie
“Coma.” In that story, a patient is placed under anesthesia for a
routine abortion. As her vital signs began to deteriorate, the
abortionist finished the abortion then tried in vain to awaken her. The
anesthesiology noted that the patient’s eyes were fixed and dilated.
In the movie, arrangements were then made to place the patient on
life support and transfer her to a facility where her body would be
maintained indefinitely. However, when the patient suddenly dies, it
prompts another physician to investigate. It was discovered that at the
secondary facility, the organs of comatose patients were auctioned off
to the highest bidder. Of course, in the movie, the illegal black market
organ-selling scheme is uncovered and the guilty are punished.
Certainly, no one is saying that the deaths of abortion patients are on purpose or that their organs are being illegally sold.
However, there is a profit motive for organ procurement companies to
ignore the unique situations posed by abortion-related deaths. When this
motive hinders an investigation and allows a dangerous abortionist to
go free, it poses a very real moral conflict.
“Understanding why healthy women are dying at abortion clinics and
identifying incompetent abortionists can also save lives,” said Newman.
“The risk of further abortion deaths should outweigh an organ
procurement company’s goal of organ harvesting and the financial
remuneration that accompanies it. What happened to Lakisha Wilson was
wrong, and we cannot allow it to happen again to someone else.”
LifeNews.com Note: Cheryl Sullenger is a leader of Operation Rescue, a pro-life that monitors abortion practitioners and exposes their illegal and unethical practices.
Abortion Clinic Killed This Woman in a Botched Abortion, Then Her Organs Were Harvested
When
Lakisha Wilson renewed her driver’s license on May 25, 2012, she
checked the permission box to become an organ donor. She had no idea
that she would be dead less than two years later, or that a simple flick
of the pen at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles would become a roadblock to
preventing those responsible for her death from being held accountable.
Lakisha Wilson was a 22-year old African-American woman who died in
March 2014, as the result of second trimester abortion complications at
Preterm, an abortion facility located in Cleveland, Ohio.
Her death not only raised questions about patient safety at the
high-volume abortion business, but also brought to light another
extremely sensitive issue that has rarely been discussed — until now.
That issue concerns the high-pressure tactics of organ procurement
organizations to secure organ donation consent from families of women
like Wilson, who die from abortion complications and other surgeries.
The news has been full of reports in recent months about
organ procurement companies contracting with Planned Parenthood and other abortion businesses to obtain
aborted baby remains
for “donation,” often to the financial benefit of both the abortion
provider and the organ procurement organization. However, there is
another aspect to the issue of organ procurement involving
dead abortion patients, which also deserves public discussion.
Certainly, organ donation to those in need of transplants is a noble
and life-saving decision under most circumstances. At any given time,
there are over 121,000 people awaiting organ transplants in the U.S. It
is true that some tragically die before a suitable donor can be found.
“We support those who wish to willingly become organ donors. In most
cases, it saves lives and gives the families of donors comfort knowing
that the death of their loved one will enable others to live,” said
Operation Rescue President Troy Newman. “However, in Lakisha Wilson’s
case, we have serious concerns about how the donation process was
handled, and how it may have actually protected those responsible for
her death.”
Second-Trimester Abortion Gone Bad
Wilson’s nightmare began on March 21, 2014, when she reported to the
Preterm abortion clinic on Shaker Boulevard in Cleveland, Ohio, for an
abortion at 19 weeks, 4 days, according to a
Preterm ultrasound report that was done about two weeks earlier. (Ultrasound
results from a different facility placed her closer to 23 weeks at the time of her abortion.)
Wilson suffered almost immediate complications during her second trimester abortion, which was conducted by Preterm abortionist
Lisa Perriera.
Even though Wilson’s blood pressure was dropping fast, Perriera
finished the abortion before tending to Wilson’s dangerously escalating
medical emergency. By then, Wilson had stopped breathing and suffered
cardiac arrest.
According to
public 911 records obtained through open records requests and
medical records
leaked to Operation Rescue, it was about thirty minutes after Wilson
suffered respiratory arrest that an ambulance was finally called. A
Preterm employee told a 911 dispatcher that Wilson was “not breathing at
all.” EMS workers arriving at the scene (after a delay caused by a
malfunctioning elevator)
noted
that Wilson indeed was not breathing. Her pupils were fixed and
dilated. They were able to restart her heart and provide oxygenation by
“bagging” her.
Wilson was eventually transported to the University Hospital Case
Medical Center where she was evaluated and given four units of packed
red blood cells to treat an apparent hemorrhage that was the source of
her cardio-respiratory failure. She was transferred to the Intensive
Care unit, placed on life support, and listed in critical but stable
condition.
Somewhere along the way, it was determined that Wilson was “brain dead.”
Lifebanc
At the University Hospital Case Medical Center, an organ procurement organization (OPO) called
Lifebanc began evaluating Wilson for organ harvesting.
Lifebanc is a non-profit OPO based in Cleveland, which claims to work with 20 Ohio hospitals to:
• Identify donors.
• Match them to patients on the National Transplant Waiting List.
• Arrange for the harvesting of organs by teams of surgeons.
• Arrange transport to hospitals for transplantation into suitable recipients.
OPOs look for donor candidates among those who are hospitalized due
to life-threatening brain injuries as the result of traffic accidents,
strokes, or lack of oxygen, according to a
video posted on Lifebanc’s web site, which was produced by
OrganDonor.gov a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Family Approached
After Wilson’s family was notified that Lakisha had been taken to the
hospital, they rushed to be by her side only to learn that their worst
fears were realized. As they gathered in a hospital waiting room in
shock and disbelief, a representative — allegedly from Preterm — first
approached them, seeking permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
CLICK LIKE IF YOU’RE PRO-LIFE!
Wilson’s grief-stricken family looked at the Preterm representative
as part of the reason why their loved one lay comatose in a hospital bed
hooked to machines that artificially controlled her life functions.
There were questions about Lakisha’s death – questions that had not
been answered. How could a healthy 22-year old woman die from what
everyone said was one of the safest and common surgical procedures in
America? What went wrong and who was responsible?
Wilson’s family refused to sign the consent forms so that the organ harvesting could begin.
Thus began a high-pressure effort to secure the family’s permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
High Demand
Why were Wilson’s organs wanted so badly?
Since African Americans are more prone to suffering from diabetes and high blood pressure than other racial groups, they are
more prone to organ failure.
It is true that organs are not supposed to be matched to donors based
on race, but there are certain important blood type characteristics and
tissue markers that are shared more often between people of the same
racial make-up. These markers help determine transplant compatibility.
In America, about 30% of all organ recipients are African American,
making them the largest minority population in need of organs for
transplant. However, this racial group comprises only about 18% of all
organ donors. Therefore, there exists a critical shortage of organs
compatible for transplant into those of African American heritage.
As a young, healthy African American woman, who succumbed to a lack
of oxygen to the brain, Wilson’s organs would have been in high demand.
Father Adamant about Not Consenting
Over the course of the next few days, Lifebanc had a vested interest in Lakisha Wilson.
At first, all testing on Wilson was ordered by hospital physicians. But on March 26, that changed.
Lifebanc ran a
search
of the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles Organ Donor database and
discovered that Wilson had given her consent to “make an anatomical
gift” of her organs upon her death.
With
this document in hand, Lifebanc did not need the family to consent
before the organ harvesting could begin. That same day, it
ordered testing to ensure that life support devices were properly placed and that Wilson’s organs were in good condition.
The next day, Wilson’s father was again approached by Lifebanc with
the request to harvest Lakisha’s organs. He adamantly refused to sign
any documents. In fact, Wilson’s records include a
hand-written note signed by Wilson’s dad, which read:
March 27, 2014. Life banc [sic] my daughter Lakisha
Wilson died under suspicious circumstances. At this time the Cuyahoga
County Coroner is investigating the cause of died [sic]. I adamantly
refuse to sign papers giving my consent for organ donation. Life banc
[sic] personnel are strongly aware of my concerns.
Lifebanc chose to ignore Wilson’s father. Paperwork was processed
that noted her father’s refusal to complete or sign any of the consent
and policy forms. While Lifebanc’s actions were technically legal, they
were ethically dubious.
Organs Procured
Over the next two days, March 27 and 28, Lifebanc ordered
additional testing
on Wilson to make sure her organs remained disease free and in good
condition for harvesting and transplant while the paperwork was
processed. Wilson wasn’t treated like a person any more. She had become a
commodity.
On March 28, against the expressed wishes of her family, and knowing
that there were questions about Wilson’s care and treatment during her
fatal abortion, Lifebanc essentially gutted Lakisha Wilson and
removed
nearly every basic internal organ, including her heart, lungs, liver,
gallbladder, pancreas, abdominal aorta, inferior vena cava, kidneys,
ureters, adrenal glands and their adjacent connective tissue.
Autopsy on Incomplete Cadaver
Thus, when the coroner, Dr. Joseph A. Felo, received what was left of
Lakisha Wilson’s body, he was forced to conduct an autopsy on a partial
cadaver. He also lacked the remains of Wilson’s aborted baby, and had
to rely on Preterm’s medical records for certain “facts” about the
supposed gestational age of her pregnancy.
Felo concluded in
Wilson’s autopsy
that she died from cardiac arrest resulting in brain damage from oxygen
deprivation, a known complication to a therapeutic abortion. In an
interview
with an investigator with the Ohio Department of Health, Felo explained
that because cardiac arrest is a known complication to a therapeutic
abortion, Wilson death “did not indicate medical malpractice.”
However, his conclusions were based on insufficient data. Why had
Wilson hemorrhaged and why wasn’t her condition treated in time by
Preterm’s abortionist, Lisa Perriera? Why did she wait a half hour after
Wilson stopped breathing to call 911?
Without Lakisha’s organs or her babies’ remains, there was no way to
determine the full extent of complications or whether Preterm staff
members were telling the truth.
Just as Wilson’s father feared if organ donation were to take place,
the “suspicious circumstances” under which his daughter died would never
be sufficiently explained.
“This complete disregard for the wishes of the family or
consideration for the circumstances of Wilson’s death make Lifebanc’s
actions troubling,” said Newman. “Wilson was kept on life support for
days — not to treat her, but for the sole purpose of keeping her organs
viable for harvesting and transplant.”
$25 Million per Year
Lifebanc is a non-profit organization that takes in about $25 million each year. According the company’s
990 tax report from 2013, the most recent year available, Lifebanc ended that fiscal year with net assets totaling more than $14 million.
The Chief Executive Officer of Lifebanc is Gordon Bowen, whose salary
$253,000 yearly with over $43,000 in additional compensation.
Lifebanc’s Medical Director is Dr. Daniel Lebovitz, a Cleveland-based
pediatrician who to be affiliated with a number of Ohio hospitals. His
annual salary in 2013 from Lifebanc alone was $101, 347.
“There appears to be good money in the organ procurement business,”
said Newman. “Combine a case with high-demand organs with financial
incentives, and it looks like we have a recipe for high-pressure tactics
to obtain consent for organ donation that include ignoring a family’s
wishes and the need for a thorough investigation into a suspicious
death.”
Others Targeted
Wilson is not the only patient suffering an abortion-related death that has been targeted for organ donation.
In 2005, Christin Gilbert, a 19-year old with Down syndrome, died
from complications to a third-trimester abortion in Wichita, Kansas.
Since Gilbert succumbed to sepsis, an infection that caused several of
her organs to fail, only her
eyes were harvested for eventual corneal transplant.
Free to Kill Again
In Gilbert’s case, the abortionists involved in her death, LeRoy
Carhart and George Tiller, were absolved of responsibility. This time,
it was not due to the inability to reach conclusions due to harvested
organs, but for politically-motivated reasons. Because he was never held
accountable, Carhart was free to kill again.
On February 7, 2014, he did just that. Another of Carhart’s third-trimester abortion patients,
Jennifer Morbelli,
died from complications. Her organs were too compromised to be suitable
for donation. Again, Carhart was not held responsible. There is a
likelihood that yet another of his abortion patients will die.
It is true that donating organs saves lives, and that is indeed
noble. However, abortion-related deaths pose unique situations that
should be taken into consideration by organ donation companies.
When organ donation conceals the incompetency of abortionists, as may
have occurred in the Wilson case, this could leave a dangerous
abortionist to kill again. Lives are endangered by the inability to
perform a thorough autopsy on a complete cadaver and get to the bottom
of what happened to cause the deaths of otherwise healthy women.
Michael Crichton’s “Coma”
The
Wilson tragedy hearkens to mind the Michael Crichton’s 1978 movie
“Coma.” In that story, a patient is placed under anesthesia for a
routine abortion. As her vital signs began to deteriorate, the
abortionist finished the abortion then tried in vain to awaken her. The
anesthesiology noted that the patient’s eyes were fixed and dilated.
In the movie, arrangements were then made to place the patient on
life support and transfer her to a facility where her body would be
maintained indefinitely. However, when the patient suddenly dies, it
prompts another physician to investigate. It was discovered that at the
secondary facility, the organs of comatose patients were auctioned off
to the highest bidder. Of course, in the movie, the illegal black market
organ-selling scheme is uncovered and the guilty are punished.
Certainly, no one is saying that the deaths of abortion patients are on purpose or that their organs are being illegally sold.
However, there is a profit motive for organ procurement companies to
ignore the unique situations posed by abortion-related deaths. When this
motive hinders an investigation and allows a dangerous abortionist to
go free, it poses a very real moral conflict.
“Understanding why healthy women are dying at abortion clinics and
identifying incompetent abortionists can also save lives,” said Newman.
“The risk of further abortion deaths should outweigh an organ
procurement company’s goal of organ harvesting and the financial
remuneration that accompanies it. What happened to Lakisha Wilson was
wrong, and we cannot allow it to happen again to someone else.”
LifeNews.com Note: Cheryl Sullenger is a leader of Operation Rescue, a pro-life that monitors abortion practitioners and exposes their illegal and unethical practices.
Abortion Clinic Killed This Woman in a Botched Abortion, Then Her Organs Were Harvested
When
Lakisha Wilson renewed her driver’s license on May 25, 2012, she
checked the permission box to become an organ donor. She had no idea
that she would be dead less than two years later, or that a simple flick
of the pen at the Bureau of Motor Vehicles would become a roadblock to
preventing those responsible for her death from being held accountable.
Lakisha Wilson was a 22-year old African-American woman who died in
March 2014, as the result of second trimester abortion complications at
Preterm, an abortion facility located in Cleveland, Ohio.
Her death not only raised questions about patient safety at the
high-volume abortion business, but also brought to light another
extremely sensitive issue that has rarely been discussed — until now.
That issue concerns the high-pressure tactics of organ procurement
organizations to secure organ donation consent from families of women
like Wilson, who die from abortion complications and other surgeries.
The news has been full of reports in recent months about
organ procurement companies contracting with Planned Parenthood and other abortion businesses to obtain
aborted baby remains
for “donation,” often to the financial benefit of both the abortion
provider and the organ procurement organization. However, there is
another aspect to the issue of organ procurement involving
dead abortion patients, which also deserves public discussion.
Certainly, organ donation to those in need of transplants is a noble
and life-saving decision under most circumstances. At any given time,
there are over 121,000 people awaiting organ transplants in the U.S. It
is true that some tragically die before a suitable donor can be found.
“We support those who wish to willingly become organ donors. In most
cases, it saves lives and gives the families of donors comfort knowing
that the death of their loved one will enable others to live,” said
Operation Rescue President Troy Newman. “However, in Lakisha Wilson’s
case, we have serious concerns about how the donation process was
handled, and how it may have actually protected those responsible for
her death.”
Second-Trimester Abortion Gone Bad
Wilson’s nightmare began on March 21, 2014, when she reported to the
Preterm abortion clinic on Shaker Boulevard in Cleveland, Ohio, for an
abortion at 19 weeks, 4 days, according to a
Preterm ultrasound report that was done about two weeks earlier. (Ultrasound
results from a different facility placed her closer to 23 weeks at the time of her abortion.)
Wilson suffered almost immediate complications during her second trimester abortion, which was conducted by Preterm abortionist
Lisa Perriera.
Even though Wilson’s blood pressure was dropping fast, Perriera
finished the abortion before tending to Wilson’s dangerously escalating
medical emergency. By then, Wilson had stopped breathing and suffered
cardiac arrest.
According to
public 911 records obtained through open records requests and
medical records
leaked to Operation Rescue, it was about thirty minutes after Wilson
suffered respiratory arrest that an ambulance was finally called. A
Preterm employee told a 911 dispatcher that Wilson was “not breathing at
all.” EMS workers arriving at the scene (after a delay caused by a
malfunctioning elevator)
noted
that Wilson indeed was not breathing. Her pupils were fixed and
dilated. They were able to restart her heart and provide oxygenation by
“bagging” her.
Wilson was eventually transported to the University Hospital Case
Medical Center where she was evaluated and given four units of packed
red blood cells to treat an apparent hemorrhage that was the source of
her cardio-respiratory failure. She was transferred to the Intensive
Care unit, placed on life support, and listed in critical but stable
condition.
Somewhere along the way, it was determined that Wilson was “brain dead.”
Lifebanc
At the University Hospital Case Medical Center, an organ procurement organization (OPO) called
Lifebanc began evaluating Wilson for organ harvesting.
Lifebanc is a non-profit OPO based in Cleveland, which claims to work with 20 Ohio hospitals to:
• Identify donors.
• Match them to patients on the National Transplant Waiting List.
• Arrange for the harvesting of organs by teams of surgeons.
• Arrange transport to hospitals for transplantation into suitable recipients.
OPOs look for donor candidates among those who are hospitalized due
to life-threatening brain injuries as the result of traffic accidents,
strokes, or lack of oxygen, according to a
video posted on Lifebanc’s web site, which was produced by
OrganDonor.gov a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Family Approached
After Wilson’s family was notified that Lakisha had been taken to the
hospital, they rushed to be by her side only to learn that their worst
fears were realized. As they gathered in a hospital waiting room in
shock and disbelief, a representative — allegedly from Preterm — first
approached them, seeking permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
CLICK LIKE IF YOU’RE PRO-LIFE!
Wilson’s grief-stricken family looked at the Preterm representative
as part of the reason why their loved one lay comatose in a hospital bed
hooked to machines that artificially controlled her life functions.
There were questions about Lakisha’s death – questions that had not
been answered. How could a healthy 22-year old woman die from what
everyone said was one of the safest and common surgical procedures in
America? What went wrong and who was responsible?
Wilson’s family refused to sign the consent forms so that the organ harvesting could begin.
Thus began a high-pressure effort to secure the family’s permission to harvest Wilson’s organs.
High Demand
Why were Wilson’s organs wanted so badly?
Since African Americans are more prone to suffering from diabetes and high blood pressure than other racial groups, they are
more prone to organ failure.
It is true that organs are not supposed to be matched to donors based
on race, but there are certain important blood type characteristics and
tissue markers that are shared more often between people of the same
racial make-up. These markers help determine transplant compatibility.
In America, about 30% of all organ recipients are African American,
making them the largest minority population in need of organs for
transplant. However, this racial group comprises only about 18% of all
organ donors. Therefore, there exists a critical shortage of organs
compatible for transplant into those of African American heritage.
As a young, healthy African American woman, who succumbed to a lack
of oxygen to the brain, Wilson’s organs would have been in high demand.
Father Adamant about Not Consenting
Over the course of the next few days, Lifebanc had a vested interest in Lakisha Wilson.
At first, all testing on Wilson was ordered by hospital physicians. But on March 26, that changed.
Lifebanc ran a
search
of the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles Organ Donor database and
discovered that Wilson had given her consent to “make an anatomical
gift” of her organs upon her death.
With
this document in hand, Lifebanc did not need the family to consent
before the organ harvesting could begin. That same day, it
ordered testing to ensure that life support devices were properly placed and that Wilson’s organs were in good condition.
The next day, Wilson’s father was again approached by Lifebanc with
the request to harvest Lakisha’s organs. He adamantly refused to sign
any documents. In fact, Wilson’s records include a
hand-written note signed by Wilson’s dad, which read:
March 27, 2014. Life banc [sic] my daughter Lakisha
Wilson died under suspicious circumstances. At this time the Cuyahoga
County Coroner is investigating the cause of died [sic]. I adamantly
refuse to sign papers giving my consent for organ donation. Life banc
[sic] personnel are strongly aware of my concerns.
Lifebanc chose to ignore Wilson’s father. Paperwork was processed
that noted her father’s refusal to complete or sign any of the consent
and policy forms. While Lifebanc’s actions were technically legal, they
were ethically dubious.
Organs Procured
Over the next two days, March 27 and 28, Lifebanc ordered
additional testing
on Wilson to make sure her organs remained disease free and in good
condition for harvesting and transplant while the paperwork was
processed. Wilson wasn’t treated like a person any more. She had become a
commodity.
On March 28, against the expressed wishes of her family, and knowing
that there were questions about Wilson’s care and treatment during her
fatal abortion, Lifebanc essentially gutted Lakisha Wilson and
removed
nearly every basic internal organ, including her heart, lungs, liver,
gallbladder, pancreas, abdominal aorta, inferior vena cava, kidneys,
ureters, adrenal glands and their adjacent connective tissue.
Autopsy on Incomplete Cadaver
Thus, when the coroner, Dr. Joseph A. Felo, received what was left of
Lakisha Wilson’s body, he was forced to conduct an autopsy on a partial
cadaver. He also lacked the remains of Wilson’s aborted baby, and had
to rely on Preterm’s medical records for certain “facts” about the
supposed gestational age of her pregnancy.
Felo concluded in
Wilson’s autopsy
that she died from cardiac arrest resulting in brain damage from oxygen
deprivation, a known complication to a therapeutic abortion. In an
interview
with an investigator with the Ohio Department of Health, Felo explained
that because cardiac arrest is a known complication to a therapeutic
abortion, Wilson death “did not indicate medical malpractice.”
However, his conclusions were based on insufficient data. Why had
Wilson hemorrhaged and why wasn’t her condition treated in time by
Preterm’s abortionist, Lisa Perriera? Why did she wait a half hour after
Wilson stopped breathing to call 911?
Without Lakisha’s organs or her babies’ remains, there was no way to
determine the full extent of complications or whether Preterm staff
members were telling the truth.
Just as Wilson’s father feared if organ donation were to take place,
the “suspicious circumstances” under which his daughter died would never
be sufficiently explained.
“This complete disregard for the wishes of the family or
consideration for the circumstances of Wilson’s death make Lifebanc’s
actions troubling,” said Newman. “Wilson was kept on life support for
days — not to treat her, but for the sole purpose of keeping her organs
viable for harvesting and transplant.”
$25 Million per Year
Lifebanc is a non-profit organization that takes in about $25 million each year. According the company’s
990 tax report from 2013, the most recent year available, Lifebanc ended that fiscal year with net assets totaling more than $14 million.
The Chief Executive Officer of Lifebanc is Gordon Bowen, whose salary
$253,000 yearly with over $43,000 in additional compensation.
Lifebanc’s Medical Director is Dr. Daniel Lebovitz, a Cleveland-based
pediatrician who to be affiliated with a number of Ohio hospitals. His
annual salary in 2013 from Lifebanc alone was $101, 347.
“There appears to be good money in the organ procurement business,”
said Newman. “Combine a case with high-demand organs with financial
incentives, and it looks like we have a recipe for high-pressure tactics
to obtain consent for organ donation that include ignoring a family’s
wishes and the need for a thorough investigation into a suspicious
death.”
Others Targeted
Wilson is not the only patient suffering an abortion-related death that has been targeted for organ donation.
In 2005, Christin Gilbert, a 19-year old with Down syndrome, died
from complications to a third-trimester abortion in Wichita, Kansas.
Since Gilbert succumbed to sepsis, an infection that caused several of
her organs to fail, only her
eyes were harvested for eventual corneal transplant.
Free to Kill Again
In Gilbert’s case, the abortionists involved in her death, LeRoy
Carhart and George Tiller, were absolved of responsibility. This time,
it was not due to the inability to reach conclusions due to harvested
organs, but for politically-motivated reasons. Because he was never held
accountable, Carhart was free to kill again.
On February 7, 2014, he did just that. Another of Carhart’s third-trimester abortion patients,
Jennifer Morbelli,
died from complications. Her organs were too compromised to be suitable
for donation. Again, Carhart was not held responsible. There is a
likelihood that yet another of his abortion patients will die.
It is true that donating organs saves lives, and that is indeed
noble. However, abortion-related deaths pose unique situations that
should be taken into consideration by organ donation companies.
When organ donation conceals the incompetency of abortionists, as may
have occurred in the Wilson case, this could leave a dangerous
abortionist to kill again. Lives are endangered by the inability to
perform a thorough autopsy on a complete cadaver and get to the bottom
of what happened to cause the deaths of otherwise healthy women.
Michael Crichton’s “Coma”
The
Wilson tragedy hearkens to mind the Michael Crichton’s 1978 movie
“Coma.” In that story, a patient is placed under anesthesia for a
routine abortion. As her vital signs began to deteriorate, the
abortionist finished the abortion then tried in vain to awaken her. The
anesthesiology noted that the patient’s eyes were fixed and dilated.
In the movie, arrangements were then made to place the patient on
life support and transfer her to a facility where her body would be
maintained indefinitely. However, when the patient suddenly dies, it
prompts another physician to investigate. It was discovered that at the
secondary facility, the organs of comatose patients were auctioned off
to the highest bidder. Of course, in the movie, the illegal black market
organ-selling scheme is uncovered and the guilty are punished.
Certainly, no one is saying that the deaths of abortion patients are on purpose or that their organs are being illegally sold.
However, there is a profit motive for organ procurement companies to
ignore the unique situations posed by abortion-related deaths. When this
motive hinders an investigation and allows a dangerous abortionist to
go free, it poses a very real moral conflict.
“Understanding why healthy women are dying at abortion clinics and
identifying incompetent abortionists can also save lives,” said Newman.
“The risk of further abortion deaths should outweigh an organ
procurement company’s goal of organ harvesting and the financial
remuneration that accompanies it. What happened to Lakisha Wilson was
wrong, and we cannot allow it to happen again to someone else.”
LifeNews.com Note: Cheryl Sullenger is a leader of Operation Rescue, a pro-life that monitors abortion practitioners and exposes their illegal and unethical practices.
Source: LifeSite News
After
years of declines, the US suicide rate rose 24% over 15 years according
to a new report from the national Centers for Disease on suicide rates
in the US from 1999-2014. The suicide rate rose for everyone between the
ages of 10-74.
During
the month of April, Unite for Reproductive and Gender Equity (URGE), a
group whose motto is “Let’s Be Bold,” embarked on their national
#AbortionPositive bus tour on 10 college campuses in five states,
including Alabama, Kansas, Ohio, Georgia, and Texas.
ST.
PAUL —Two initiatives strongly backed by Minnesota Citizens Concerned
for Life (MCCL), the state’s oldest and largest pro-life organization,
were approved today on the floor of the House of Representatives. A ban
on taxpayer funded abortions passed on a 76-53 vote and a requirement
that abortion facilities be licensed and inspected was adopted on a
76-52 vote.
Like
most pro-lifers I believe passionately in the power of communications
that touch both the heart and the head. That is why every time a
particularly powerful music video comes my way, I try to share it with
our readers.
Abortion
is touted as a woman’s choice, but according to one study, 64% of women
feel pressured into abortion by their partners. Men may pressure their
partners into having abortions because they do not want a child and do
not want to pay child support.
I
like to think that even though my politics are as far away from
President Obama’s is as the East is from the West, I can give him the
benefit of the doubt when he deserves it.
About
a week ago my mother told me that she had an abortion before I was
born. It devastated me. Mourning someone I have never met seems bizarre
to me, yet I am so sad. To help me find closure I wrote my half sibling,
that I will never meet, a letter.
Posts
