Baby Joseph is a 13-month old infant in London, Ontario, Canada, who suffers from an incurable neurological disease that will result in his eventual death. London's Victoria hospital, where Joseph has been a patient since October, originally planned to remove life support from the baby over the objections of his parents. The hospital asked the Office of the Public Guardian to assume decision-making power. This situation is what has made national headlines.
There is no doubt that the outcome of this case will have worldwide consequences in the areas of euthanasia, parental rights and national health care.
Baby Joseph's parents understand that he has no chance of recovery, but have requested that the baby have a tracheostomy (a permanent tracheotomy) so that they can bring him home to die. Their daughter died from a similar disorder eight years ago; but in her case, the physicians performed a tracheostomy, and the family was able to take her home to die.
The case made news in the United States when Father Frank Pavone, the Euthanasia Prevention Coalition and the Terri Schiavo Life and Hope Network came to the support of the parents. There is a debate over the cognitive function of the baby. The hospital has said he is not responsive. The parents claim that he responds to voice, touch and pain. In a recently released video, the baby is shown clearly responding to all three.
The debate centers around 2 issues.
Keep in mind that Gabriella Gifford, the Arizona Congresswoman who was shot in the head, received a tracheotomy almost immediately. Tracheotomies are performed for many reasons, but for long-term ventilatory support they are done for comfort. The question I would ask as a medical professional is, since the baby has been hospitalized since October, why wasn't the tracheostomy performed months earlier? This is standard procedure in hospitals.
There is a lot more to this case that is unfolding. As of today, the hospital is refusing to release the medical records.
Dr. Peters on Sr. Walsh’s piece in America Magazine - The distinguished canonist Ed Peters has a response to a piece from Sr. Mary Ann Walsh, who used to work at the USCCB and who now writes for Jesuit-run A...
53 minutes ago